Hôtels à New Town, Édimbourg

Points positifs: Fantastic facilities and very friendly and helpful staff

Points positifs: Low key luxury hotel in a central area. Close to main sightseeings and dining are very cost and full of natural light. Free snacks as well.

Points négatifs: Solo room is a bit small and separated, far less valued than classic double room. Parking is a problem, better preserved with the hotel in advance.

Points positifs: Espaces décorés avec goût, restauration e celle te, environnement chic et confortable

Points positifs: This is a beautiful hotel and a great use of these historic buildings.

Points négatifs: The food and service in the dining room was quirky and often not what we wanted. Better staff training and supervision along with a new executive chef would be most helpful

Points positifs: Gym and Spa services. Baba was an excellent restaurant.

Points négatifs: Minor issue: didn’t get a bar of soap.

Points positifs: Overall a great hotel in the heart of the city

Points négatifs: That I had to come back home

Points négatifs: Bruit dans la chambre

Points positifs: Convenient to where I was going - Usher Hall and EdBookfestival

Points négatifs: Cramped room. No easy chair for reading. Sluggish shower drain, threatening to swamp bathroom floor. Sour milk, so coffee ruined.

Points positifs: Clean and comfortable

Points positifs: Love the situation, the look and design, the variety of spaces...

Points négatifs: Some traces of aging (bathroom ceiling), but nothing of a real problem.

Points positifs: The staff were MORE than great in loads of ways, but most of all, I left some sentimental item in the room. I felt like they moved heaven and earth to get them back to me. Breakfast was really busy, ( festival time) and I watched the team ALL operate at 150% to please everyone Also, the decor was inspiring Bed super comfy. Huge towels, ample products in bathroom.

Points négatifs: Nothing!

Points positifs: L’emplacement de l’hôtel en plein centre. La grande chambre 320 avec Velux.

Points négatifs: Le petit-déjeuner (organisation, service, choix pas en adéquation avec le niveau de l’hôtel).

Points positifs: The location was perfect, the staff very helpful and the rooms were good size and perfectly clean.... I would definately stay at this hotel again

Points positifs: Hotelroom

Points négatifs: Temperature in bar very cold, barkeeper not very friendly (I have no time to make tea)

Points positifs: location and staff

Points négatifs: air conditioning-room was too hot at night.

Points positifs: comfort and proximity to the highlights of the city Had stayed there on previous occasions

Points positifs: Relaxing time spent with a friend. Enjoyed Indian head massage although would have preferred it without a top on rather than my arms and shoulders being massaged over my clothes!

Points négatifs: The breakfast on Saturday was cold...the sausages & bacon were undercooked!

Points positifs: Vieux établissement très classique et chic (d'époque), chambres très grandes et confortables, excellent lits et duvets, chocolats de bienvenue, possibilité de se faire du thé et café.

Points négatifs: Un peu bruyant car au centre! mais ca ne m'a pas empêché de très bien dormir!

Points positifs: tres bon hotel, ideal pour shopping et visite de la ville. on peut tout faire a pied. personnel très serviable et les chambres très bien et calmes. ns y retournerons avec plaisir

Points positifs: Le petit déjeuner et sa situation géographique

Points négatifs: très bruyant, ascenseur très lent (et qui grinçait énormément), personnel pas toujours très sympathique

Points positifs: Très bien situé et très confortable

Points positifs: la chambre bien qu'assez petite avait été rénové avec goût et de qualité

Points négatifs: le lobby et couloir de la partie ancienne de l'hôtel mériterait d'être rénovée et d'être meublée avec des meubles de qualité fauteuils tapis, comptoir accueil…). Ils ne correspondent pas au standing de l'hôtel et le desservent et c'est la première chose qu'on remarque.

Points positifs: J'ai bien apprécié la décoration des chambres et la salle de bain était très agréable à vivre.Hôtel bien situé.

Points négatifs: Par contre le lit était beaucoup trop petit pour 2.

Points positifs: emplacement centre ville; chambre spacieuse;decoration trés "typique" écossaise;spa et fitness; respect del'architecture victorienne

Points négatifs: un peu "poussiereux"!

Points positifs: Bien situé et personnel excellent

Points positifs: Hotel très bien placé. très bons conseils sur un restaurant dans Édimbourg.

Points négatifs: Avoir des peignoirs dans la chambre pour aller au spa. et supprimer le 1 $ pur fermer son casier au spa, pas pratique ni du standing de Hotel.

Points positifs: Love that full breakfast is available in room and you just pay the tray charge (if breakfast is already included in your rate). Upgraded (paid offer) to a duplex deluxe - so worth it.

Points négatifs: Felt sorry for reception, really tight and congested with piles of baggage to take care of in view behind the front desk (damaging interior design and walls). Appreciate it's an historic building but steps leading up to elevator foyer really not helpful. Whole lobby area could do with a revamp so that it becomes guest (and staff) centric not process centric.

Points positifs: Everything

Points négatifs: I got food poisoning in the restaurant night one

Points négatifs: Expensive for what it is

Points positifs: Great location, good access to shops and restaurants, easy to get to.

Points positifs: Lits très confortables, personnel très courtois, concierge géniale!!!

Points négatifs: Prix du petit déjeuner Travaux aux alentours d’où difficultés d’accès au stationnement

Points positifs: la décoration était sympa et les cosmétiques mis à notre disposition sentaient bon.

Points négatifs: le carrelage non fini de la salle de bain et la chasse d'eau pas bien située des toilettes (on devait baisser la lunette des toilettes à chaque fois qu'on devait tirer la chasse

Points positifs: Great breakfast

Points négatifs: Rooms a bit small

Points positifs: Location / staff / clean / excellent breakfast with fabulous staff. I do recommend it for anyone visiting Edinburgh

Points négatifs: Nothing

Points positifs: Excellent location, very friendly staff

Points positifs: Breakfast options were good - a wide variety of choice. The room was nice and spacious (but I did take an upgrade to a Georgian room). Staff were very friendly.

Points négatifs: Sometimes the cooked breakfast items were not so warm. The plates were super-hot, but the food itself (like scrambled eggs) not so much. The bed mattress was too soft for my liking.

Points positifs: The location was very good

Points négatifs: Our room was in the ground floor room 113 our outlook was the bins. Four am the bins were emptied 6 am the beer barrels arrived

Points positifs: L'emplacement était super et la vue est superbe depuis le jardin sur le toit. Nous avons vraiment adoré notre chambre. Tous les membres du personnel étaient extrêmement sympathiques.

Points positifs: Magnifique mobilier, système stéréo Bose, baies vitrées, cabine douche en verre, baignoire séparée. Très charmant jardin de toit et salon commun. Le personnel est très accommodant.

Points positifs: Location.

Points négatifs: Room temp too warm. Breakfast too expensive.

Points positifs: Spent the first 2 nights of my married life in the hotel. Great place. Glad we stayed.

Points positifs: We arrived early on Saturday around 8:30 am. We knew we were way too early for check in but they said they could probably get us in before 12:00. As we finished breakfast next door they rang the room was ready. We were escorted to our room and the bags had been delivered. Very happy with the friendly and personal service.

Points négatifs: It all went downhill from there. The shower had little pressure and the shower head broke trying to adjust it. We then noticed pieces of broken glass around the bathroom floor. These were clearly visible and hard to miss. Luckily we didn’t step on them. We asked for the shower head to be fixed and the glass cleaned up. The shower head was fixed when we returned but we had to call again for the glass. I absolutely hate when there is no socket in the bathroom. The only plugs were no where near a mirror which makes blow drying your hair quite fun. It would be good if someone who designed the rooms actually had to use it. A vanity mirror for makeup and hair on the desk would solve this issue. Breakfast, hum. At first I thought this would be positive as our first breakfast was great. The second one not so much. First the waitress forgot to put in our order. When we had to ask for it and it finally showed up the egg was undercooked (and I like them runny) and you needed a saw to cut through the toast. When we checked out they wanted to charge us for breakfast and we had to tell them they were pre-paid. If you provide Nespresso capsules they should be refilled.

Points négatifs: Thought there would have been a pool and spa

Points positifs: The staff were 1st class but the rooms difficult to access as we had to go u to the 3rd floor to access a 1st floor room. Too many stairs and at least 2 of my friends could not have managed. Overall the rooms were very good , the staff excellent but the layout very poor.

Points positifs: Awesome property with very kind and understanding staff

Points négatifs: Nothing

Points positifs: Excellent stay! The staff was friendly and eager to please. The room was clean and the bed was luxurious. The bar and rooftop patio were a wonderful surprise and the location was great. A short walk to the Royal Mile and close to the train station.

Points positifs: Maintenance staff, helped with luggage problem

Points négatifs: Bathroom sink would not drain, hotel seemed old

Points positifs: Ambience of the bar & cocktail choices

Points positifs: Comfy bed. Friendly staff. Super breakfast.

Points négatifs: Not enough coffee/tea etc in room. Shower pressure very poor. Need more complimentary tea and coffee and sugar etc

Points positifs: La salle de bains La machine à café Bonne connexion Wi Fi

Points négatifs: Personnel souriant mais faussement efficace en particulier au petit déjeuner Petit déjeuner inférieur à ce qui se fait dans les hôtels de même catégorie notamment au Mariott à Glasgow où nous étions Ambiance un peu triste et artificielle

Points positifs: L emplacement près de Princess street, le bar , la terrasse de la chambre , il faut prendre les chambres du dernier étage.

Points négatifs: Très grand hôtel , couloir interminable, aurait besoin d un coup de fraîcheur. Musique dans le couloir. Petite chambre peu de place pour ranger les affaires. Petit déjeuner moyen pour un 5 étoiles .

Points négatifs: Tout

Points positifs: Bien situé et la réception étaient superbes.

Points négatifs: La chambre était horrible. Très chaud. On ne pouvait pas ouvrir la fenêtre, l'air conditionné ne marchait pas. Le personnel ne faisait rien pour vous aider.

Points positifs: Location very good. Very comfortable bed. Staff friendly.

Points positifs: Location and cost versus adventages

Points négatifs: More varieties in the breakfast

Points positifs: Nothing particularly. Staff too busy ,breakfast not great , reception desk poor.

Points négatifs: Reception Breakfast was poor Directions/ layout of rooms in hotel confusing

Points positifs: L’emplacement

Points négatifs: Le bruit de la ventilation en panne l’attente de décision de changement de chambre (2 heues30!!) et dû descendre bagages un comble de la non décision

Points positifs: The location is very central to many Edinburgh sites. The rooms are large and clean. The hotel is a former mansion so it is very elegant. The staff is excellent.

Points négatifs: The bathroom was very small. The hotel has no parking so I had to park 10 minutes away in a car park that costs 22 pounds a day. Our wakeup call was missed two different days.

Points positifs: Great location, nice room with excellent bathroom, and great coffee shop located on property. Free snacks and water in the room was a nice treat.

Points négatifs: Nothing I can really complain about. We really enjoyed our stay here.

Points positifs: Location only

Points négatifs: I was unhappy at all I give this hotel one star, the service for the room was bad, they not clean the room proper and don’t change the bed covered

Points positifs: Great location. Friendly helpful staff. Quick easy checkin and checkout. Room comfortable, clean and really quiet. Lovely breakfast. All set in a lovely old restored building.

Points positifs: God location. Nice interior.

Points négatifs: Breakfast buffet could be refilled continuesly. Staff at breakfast, could have more attention to the guests.

Points positifs: Very nice rooms and staff very helpful

Points négatifs: Air con was poor so had to open window so noisy Saturday night

Points positifs: No breakfast room service, WiFi exceedingly slow or non existent, drapery valences just left in hallway for our 4 day stay, often with maid’s trolley nearby, bathroom too small to put our toiletries in, toilet ran so we called for repairs, but in 3 days, no one responded. Most difficult was that our room in a grand hotel was actually an attic , reached by only one elevator shared by linen and cleaning staff at times. We were charged about $500 a night for this room in the old building, not what we expected. Intercontinental has some work to do! Staff were all lovely and helpful.

Points négatifs: See above!!! We asked to move and pay for upgrade if necessary, but we were told nothing was available. Groups stayed here. I made reservation in the spring. Maybe we were displaced by members of a group tour?

Points positifs: L' aspect très écossais de cet hotel, le bar et son ambiance . Chambre superbe et très confortable . Personnel très pro. Situation au plus près des axes touristiques et des resto.

Points positifs: The whole hotel experience at the George Hotel was completely faultless. The staff were incredibly helpful and welcoming. The rooms were spotless, warm and very comfortable. The breakfasts were delicious. The flight was cancelled on our return and had to stay at the George Hotel an extra night, the staff welcomed us back with mulled wine! Excellent stay, thank you.

Points positifs: Le calme de cet hôtel est très appréciable...

Points négatifs: Je tiens à vous préciser que j'ai réservé une chambre sur booking.com, site sur lequel cette chambre figurait comme une chambre au tarif normal de près de 700 livres la nuit et qui était proposée à moins de 200 livres la nuit. J'ai donc opté pour cette chambre. Mais notre déception fut grande lorsque nous avons constaté que la chambre en question était une chambre spécialement aménagée pour des personnes handicapées. Je trouve que la moindre des choses eut été que cela fut mentionné sur le site lors de la réservation. Pourquoi? Simplement pour les raisons suivantes. Le lavabo de la salle de bain est à hauteur d'une personne dans un fauteuil roulant. Idem pour la douche. Pas de réfrigérateur dans la chambre. C'est du vol!

Points positifs: The hotel kindly acknowledged our anniversary. All the staff were wonderful.

Points positifs: Brilliant location for all the reasons anyone would visit Edinburgh - sites shops reatauramts

Points positifs: enjoyed the comfort and eating at the restaurant

Points positifs: The hotel was in central Edinburgh and close to all the attractions.the room was very spacious

Points négatifs: Lack of parking as public parking very expensive.

Points positifs: Bon hôtel très bien situe

Points négatifs: prélève l'argent dès la réservation (même si cela est fait plusieurs mois avant)

Points positifs: le service

Points positifs: La qualite generale des prestations, le petit dejeuner haut de gamme et la situation geographique de l'hotel.

Points positifs: location, standard of accommodation

Points négatifs: bedrooms were very warm even with no heating on. We were unable to open a window due to noise on street. This was a minor complaint.

Points positifs: I booked a room at The George Hotel as a special birthday treat for my husband. I wanted somewhere right in the city and this was the perfect location, we even managed to find a parking space! The staff were really friendly and helpful. The room was lovely and the bed was possibly the most comfortable I have ever stayed in!

Points positifs: The staff were very friendly and helped as much as they could with my enquiries

Points négatifs: The rooms were very stuffy and hot. I had to request a fan and only a very small one could be found . Staff helped as best as they could. Paid to buffet breakfast but as i has to leave by 7.30 i was supplied with a take away that consisted of a cold croissant and a yoghurt. It was disappointing, would rather had a refund.

Points positifs: Comfortable bed

Points négatifs: Old building. Original windows. Room on street side no sound proofing all street noise and traffic can be heard so disturbing for light sleepers... No dining facilities at the hotel.... Breakfast is arranged by hotel with a restaurant across the road from the hotel..

Points négatifs: Chambre (110) bruyante à cause d'une turbine ou moteur extérieur qui tourne en permanence joue/nuit et vue sur un arrière de bâtiment vétuste

Points positifs: Emplacement idéal: calme mais à 5mn d'une premiere rue pietonne pleine de pubs et à 10mn de Prince Street Confortable Petit déjeuner au Rable: pas de buffet mais carte assez variée. Ce n'est pas très copieux mais c'est correct.

Points négatifs: Prix élevé dû à la période (le mois d'août est celui du festival: Edimbourg est bondé et les prix des hotels sont multipliés par 4 ou 5. Du coup la chambre nous a été facturée 260€ alors que c'est une chambre dont le juste prix serait de 70-80€

Points positifs: Everything was fine

Points négatifs: The Fan in the bathroom was too noisy

Points positifs: The location is amazing. Just off Princes Street, right in the heart of Edinburgh - fantastic for tourists! The hotel is very tidy and our room was very spacious. There's also free drinking water on each floor - a great little benefit which you don't usually find in hotels. We had a room towards the back, it was nice and quiet.

Points négatifs: Shame that breakfast is not offered in the hotel but across the room. We didn't take them up on the offer but apart from that minor point, nothing we didnt like :)

Points positifs: Emplacement parfait pour visiter la ville Disponibilité du personnel

Points négatifs: Chambres un peu vétustes

Points positifs: Very clean and comfortable. Close to Rose Lane with its restaurants and cafes.

Points positifs: The staff were excellent.

Points négatifs: The bed wasn't very comfy and it was a wee bit small.you would have thought the hotel would have thrown in breakfast with the price of the room.

Points positifs: Excellent staff - really helpful and friendly. Great location.

Points positifs: Room was comfortable and spacious. The breakfast accross the road at Rabbles was wonderful

Points positifs: The location was excellent, the staff was helpful.

Points négatifs: Our room was uncomfortably warm in spite of having a fan in the room.